In days of yore, advertising was a pretty simple business.
You created an ad and then stuck it in front of your chosen target audience over and over again until they bought what you were selling.
Develop your message and repeat, repeat, repeat.
OK it was never really THAT easy. But compared to the advertising landscape we’re faced with today, it was a walk in the park.
The brand consistency problem
When we’re trying to advertise (or engage) across multiple platforms like TikTok, Instagram, YouTube and LinkedIn among others, we’ve got a bit of a problem – essentially caused by different (but often overlapping) audiences, with different motivations for using that platform at any particular point in time.
So, what gets the algorithms firing on TikTok usually falls by the wayside on LinkedIn.
As a result (and completely understandably) brands feel compelled to adapt their campaigns, or create bespoke activity tailored to each channel.
But if we’re trying to optimise the creative for the algorithm, we risk losing our brand identity.
It might be OK to be silly and superficial on TikTok. But on LinkedIn?
Your audience might be on both.
This is essentially the dilemma of creative fragmentation. There can often be a tension between platform-specific approaches and the traditional wisdom of brand consistency, in that gaining traction on different platforms often demands different executions.
The danger of short-term thinking
In the race for engagement, many brands fall into the trap of chasing engagement metrics at the expense of their long-term strategy. Short-term tactics that boost metrics like clicks, views and shares don’t always contribute to meaningful brand-building.
Worse, they can confuse audiences about what the brand stands for.
Let’s consider a blindingly obvious hypothetical example.
By nature, a firm of solicitors must project trust, professionalism, and ultimately, seriousness.
TikTok is fun, light-hearted, and often irreverent.
If this fictitious (for legal reasons) legal firm decides they want to appeal to a younger audience, they may choose to adopt a slightly wacky approach to gain TikTok engagement. But by doing so, it risks eroding its credibility.
Maybe nobody’s that dumb, but the point is that instead of letting the platform dictate brand behaviour, the brand should choose the media that aligns best with its identity (and target audience). Instead of chasing engagement, this (entirely made up) legal firm should focus on deeper, more meaningful content.
And if that means staying away from TikTok, then so be it.
Is consistency the answer?
Yes, it is. The power of consistency in branding can’t be overstated. Repetition builds recognition, familiarity, trust and ultimately, brand equity.
But consistency isn’t just about repeating the same tagline or visual ideas endlessly. That can only go so far at the best of times, let alone when we’re dealing with countless advertising platforms.
It’s about creating long-term brand value, not short-term optimisation.
The answer lies at the heart of the brand – in its positioning, narrative, and purpose.
It’s about staying true to who you are.
Brands like Nike have proven that you can deliver hundreds of unique campaigns, as long as every one of them is loyal to the spirit of the brand. Each execution or campaign feels different, yet all are unmistakably Nike. Why? Because they’re rooted in the same organising thought of inspiring human potential through sport (or something like that).
If you build a strong foundation, you can flex the execution – as long as it’s fully consistent with the core brand narrative.
Establish your hierarchy first
The key to delivering long-term consistency lies in establishing a strong brand hierarchy.
At the top sits the core brand idea – the “organising thought” that guides everything you do.
Below that, individual creative executions can adapt to the needs of audiences and different media, as long as they remain visually and spiritually ‘on brand’.
Here’s what you do.
- Craft a clear, single-minded statement that encapsulates your brand’s purpose and positioning
- Define your organising thought – what’s your Just do it?
- Identify the visual and verbal cues that make your brand recognisable, and use them consistently – ensuring your brand guidelines are flexible enough to accommodate different media
- Train your teams – ensure everyone involved in your marketing comms team understands the brand’s core idea and how to execute it across channels
- Audit your campaigns – regularly review creative executions across different channels to ensure they are consistent with the underlying brand positioning and visual identity
The fragmented media landscape is here to stay
The media landscape isn’t going to get any less complicated and, without doubt, brands will need to continue to adapt – but that doesn’t mean abandoning brand consistency. By rooting all activity in a clear brand hierarchy and staying true to your organising thought, you can flex your brand without breaking it.
Simples.
